Old One
Arcane
Do people do the crafting? The sheer number of uncategorized components seemed kind of a pain in my partial playthrough.
I did quite a bit of crafting. It was fun at first trying to figure out different formulae, but it eventually stopped being fun, so I used a guide for the rest. There are some useful items that can be made. ((Creepy Eyeball + Fairy Dust) + Leather Helmet) is a nice one for a scout.
If you're going to craft a 2-handed weapon, I'd go for a spear. They have a range of 6 as opposed to 4 for swords and axes, which is a significant advantage for a number of reasons. A spear combined with Whirlwind is excellent.
If there's a way to craft hammers, which is what I wanted, I couldn't find it. You can make a spiked club, but it's pretty boring.